LystrDigest
Direct listing

Why 2026's record year for direct listings has gone badly for investors

The direct listing began in 2018 with large, well-funded technology companies. Since 2022 it has been used mostly by microcaps, with poor first-day…

Nov 21, 20264 min read
4min read
4sources
3topics
Nov 21published

When Spotify listed on the New York Stock Exchange in April 2018 without an underwritten offering, the direct listing was presented as a challenge to the IPO. Eight years later the structure is used more than ever, by a very different kind of company and with very different results.

2018 to 2021: large, well-known, well-funded

Spotify sold no shares. It registered the shares its existing holders already owned, the exchange set a reference price, and trading opened in an auction. The company’s reasons were specific. It did not need capital, it was widely known, and it had a large group of shareholders who could supply stock on the first day.

Slack followed in 2019, Palantir and Asana in 2020, and Roblox and Coinbase in 2021. Each fitted the same description: a large private company with a recent funding round to anchor valuation, no need for proceeds and enough existing holders to make a market.

The rules that followed

The original structure had one limitation. The company could not raise money. The exchanges moved to change that. The SEC approved the NYSE’s rule for a primary direct listing, in which the company itself sells shares in the opening auction, on Dec. 22, 2020, and Nasdaq’s version in May 2021.

The primary direct listing has seen little use. The companies large enough to attract an opening auction that could absorb a capital raise have mostly preferred an underwritten IPO.

The courts added a complication. In Slack Technologies v. Pirani in 2023, the Supreme Court held that a plaintiff suing under Section 11 of the Securities Act must show that the shares purchased were registered under the registration statement in question. In a direct listing, registered and unregistered shares begin trading together and cannot easily be told apart. The decision narrowed issuer liability and gave investors a reason for caution.

2022 to 2026: the microcap direct listing

The companies using the structure changed. Jay Ritter of the University of Florida, who tracks every U.S. direct listing, notes that from 2022 onward the companies doing them have generally been microcap stocks.

2026 has been the busiest year yet. D&O Diary, citing one dataset, counted 18 direct listings through August. Renaissance Capital reported in September that direct listings were having a record year by number and that the year’s group averaged a 71% decline from first trade, with one stock above its opening price.

Why the results differ

The 2018 design assumed conditions that most small companies do not have.

A price anchor. Spotify’s shares had traded privately and it had recent funding rounds. Many small direct listings have no recent arm’s-length transaction, and the reference price rests on a valuation report.

Natural buyers. A widely known company draws institutional and retail demand on the first day without marketing. An unknown company with no underwriter and no roadshow has had no process for finding buyers.

Balanced supply. In a direct listing existing holders can sell from the first trade, with no lock-up unless they have agreed to one. If early investors bought at a fraction of the reference price, many will sell into the opening.

A funded balance sheet. A company that lists without raising capital and needs money soon afterwards will finance at the post-listing price, often through an equity line or a discounted placement, which adds supply.

When those four conditions are absent, the opening auction meets heavy supply and thin demand, and the price falls until it finds buyers.

What the exchanges have done

Nasdaq’s response has been to tighten entry. The discretionary rule adopted in December 2025 allows the exchange to refuse a company whose expected float and distribution raise concentration concerns. China-based issuers may now direct list only on the Global Select Market.

When the structure works

The direct listing remains sound where its original conditions are met, at any size. That means a company that has raised capital recently from a broad group of investors at a price it can point to, that has cash for at least a year, whose significant holders have agreed to a lock-up or a staged release, and that has done the investor relations work an underwriter would otherwise do.

It also means treating the listing and the financing as two steps. A private placement before the listing sets the price anchor and funds the company. The listing then provides liquidity without the company depending on the first day’s trading for capital.

Sponsor’s view

From Andy Altahawi, Adamson Brothers Corp., the sponsor of this publication. Direct listings are my field, and this year’s record is a fair warning. The structure works when a company arrives with a real price reference, a broad shareholder base, committed holders and money in the bank. It fails when it is used as a cheaper way to reach an exchange by a company that has none of those. The difference is in the preparation before the first trade.

Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

Related